Nestlé India has delivered a 62% total shareholder return over the past five years, despite a recent 12% drop in share price. While earnings per share grew at 12% annually, the market's pessimism is reflected in a P/E ratio of 66.83, indicating potential undervaluation. Shareholders have seen a 7.4% decline this year, contrasting with a 26% market rise, suggesting a need for careful evaluation of the company's fundamentals.